Tesla Car Insurance Costs: A Complete Price Breakdown by Model

By Michael Thornton

April 30, 2025 at 04:13 AM

Tesla insurance costs vary significantly across models and locations. The Model 3 is the most affordable to insure at $2,221 annually ($185 monthly), while the Model X costs the most at $3,831 annually ($319 monthly). For comparison, insuring a 3-year-old Toyota Camry averages $2,294 annually.

Key factors affecting Tesla insurance costs:

  • Vehicle cost ($38,990 - $79,990 base prices)
  • Expensive repair costs (battery replacement ~$13,000)
  • Aluminum body construction
  • Limited repair facilities (Tesla service centers only)
  • Location-specific rates

Tesla Insurance, available in 12 states, determines rates using:

  • Real-time driving behavior
  • Safety Score (0-100)
  • Miles driven
  • Location
  • Vehicle model
  • Coverage selected
  • Number of insured vehicles

The company claims to offer ~20% savings compared to traditional insurers. Unlike other providers, Tesla Insurance doesn't consider:

  • Age
  • Gender
  • Credit history
  • Accident history
  • Traffic violations

Cheapest insurance providers by model:

  • Model 3: Travelers ($149/month)
  • Model Y: Nationwide ($171/month)
  • Model S: Travelers ($216/month)
  • Model X: Progressive ($231/month)

To find the best rates:

  • Compare multiple insurers
  • Consider regional companies
  • Check Tesla Insurance if available in your state
  • Review coverage needs carefully
  • Look beyond price at service quality

All rates mentioned are for full coverage insurance with good driving history and credit. Individual rates will vary based on personal factors and location.

Related Articles

Previous Articles